November 2026

BCSC: Why Pursue the Men Who Lost Millions While Failing to Answer Questions About Those Who Allegedly Profited?

The BCSC's Own Findings Tell a Different Story About Michael Lathigee, Earle Pasquill and the Collapse of Freedom Investment Club

By Michael Lathigee
November 2026

For more than a decade, the British Columbia Securities Commission (BCSC) has pursued Earle Pasquill and me over the collapse of the Freedom Investment Club (FIC).

The Commission has imposed enormous financial penalties, pursued our personal assets, and repeatedly publicized its enforcement victories.

But there is a critical part of this story the public rarely hears.

Earle Pasquill and I were the largest financial losers when FIC collapsed. In fact, based on our investment records, I maintain that each of us lost more of his own money than any other individual FIC investor.

We were not businessmen who walked away with millions in personal profits while investors suffered.

We had substantial personal wealth invested in the businesses. We worked to build those businesses, and when they collapsed, our own financial losses were devastating. There was also a complete collapse of the Real Estate Industry due to the subprime mortgage crisis that impacted Alberta also and land values dropped significantly and TD Bank withdrew its financing although our companies were in good standing with our loans and with no one buying it was a situation in which many other real estate companies collapsed.

The BCSC's own published findings contain evidence supporting an important distinction between money raised for the FIC companies and money raised to enrich Earle and me personally.

Yet this distinction has received little attention in the public narrative.

The BCSC's Own Words: Where Did the $21.7 Million Go?

The Commission's March 2015 sanctions decision, reported as 2015 BCSECCOM 78, contains two especially important findings.

In paragraph 12, the Commission stated:

"The evidence before us indicates that the bulk of the $21.7 million was used for the benefit of the FIC Group of companies."

Read those words carefully.

This was not a statement from my lawyer. This was not my personal interpretation of banking records.

This was the BCSC's own finding.

The Commission acknowledged that the bulk of the $21.7 million went toward the FIC group of businesses.

In paragraph 16, the Commission addressed our argument concerning personal enrichment. Earle and I argued that the conduct was not designed to enrich us personally.

The Commission responded:

"If we had found that the fraud was designed to enrich them, that would be an aggravating factor."

The Commission declined to treat the absence of such a finding as a mitigating factor.

That legal distinction is important. The Commission did not declare that neither of us ever received any personal benefit. But its decision did not find that the fraud was designed to enrich us personally.

These are material facts.

The Commission nevertheless found securities civil fraud not criminal fraud arising from inadequate disclosure of FIC's financial condition and the diversion of funds raised for foreclosure investments into other FIC companies. I continue to dispute the fairness of the broader proceedings and their public portrayal. The BCSC seems to partake in the writings of journalists that this was a criminal fraud. It was a civil adjudication where the judge and jury was the BCSC.

But the BCSC's findings concerning the destination of the money deserve the same public attention as its findings concerning our responsibility.

If the bulk of the $21.7 million benefited the FIC companies, why has so much of the public narrative focused on Earle and me as though we personally pocketed those millions?

We Lost More Than the Investors We Were Accused of Defrauding

One of the most painful aspects of this entire affair is the failure to acknowledge our personal financial losses.

Earle and I were not outside promoters collecting fees and disappearing when the businesses failed.

We were founders, managers, and substantial investors. This does not take away of course from the pain of the investors who also lost money and I have had great sadness for many years and made efforts to pursue the persons you see below to try and recover monies for investors. Also I made a payment of $350000 to the BCSC of which none of it went to the investors that they said they were representing. What did the BCSC do with this money I paid?

We committed our own financial resources to the success of FIC and its underlying projects.

I maintain that our individual losses exceeded those of every other individual investor.

This is a significant fact because it challenges the popular impression that we benefited financially while everyone else suffered.

We suffered alongside our investors, and our personal financial exposure was greater.

I lost substantial personal wealth. Earle also suffered enormous financial losses.

We had every financial incentive to see the projects succeed.

We stood to benefit from successful businesses, not from their collapse.

Why would two men with substantial personal money committed to their companies deliberately seek to destroy those investments?

The BCSC's legal findings do not disappear because we lost money. But our financial losses are relevant to understanding our motivations, the nature of the business collapse, and the difference between personal enrichment and corporate failure.

A balanced account should explain those facts.

Instead, the public has repeatedly been presented with enormous financial penalties and allegations of fraud, without comparable attention to the personal fortunes we lost.

The Other Side of the Story: Denis O'Dowd and Phoenix Land Ventures

While the BCSC has continued pursuing Earle and me, serious questions remain concerning individuals involved in the underlying Alberta real estate transactions.

One of those individuals is Denis O'Dowd.

The Alberta litigation involving Phoenix Land Ventures Ltd. is identified as follows:

Court of King's Bench of Alberta
Judicial Centre: Edmonton
Court File No. 2003 19532

Applicants:

  • Alberta Fund 1, LLC
  • Prima Projects Canada LLC
  • Prima Equity Partners, Inc.

Respondents:

  • Phoenix Land Ventures Ltd.
  • Denis O'Dowd
  • Valerie O'Dowd

The proceedings concern corporate obligations and efforts to establish responsibility for debts associated with Phoenix Land Ventures.

I allege that transactions involving Denis O'Dowd resulted in substantial losses involving FIC investor funds.

I believe the financial records and property transactions warrant comprehensive investigation, including the question of whether individuals personally retained money that should have benefited FIC investors.

The distinction is fundamental.

Earle and I lost substantial personal money when our businesses collapsed.

I allege that other individuals involved in transactions with FIC received substantial financial benefits.

Why has the BCSC not publicly explained whether it investigated these allegations and traced the relevant payments?

Malcolm Lennie and John Tansowny: Follow the Money

The Law Society of Alberta's disciplinary proceedings involving former lawyer Malcolm Lennie raise additional questions.

Lennie resigned from the legal profession following proceedings concerning serious admitted professional misconduct.

The disciplinary record includes findings concerning conflicts of interest, failures to protect clients, and improper handling of trust funds.

His involvement in FIC-related transactions makes those findings relevant to the broader history of the investments.

John Tansowny was also involved in locating and negotiating Alberta real estate opportunities for FIC.

I believe transactions involving Tansowny, Lennie, and O'Dowd deserve detailed financial examination.

Who received the purchase proceeds? Were properties transferred at inflated prices? Did undisclosed parties receive financial benefits? Were investors' interests adequately protected?

I allege that substantial amounts of investor money were lost through questionable transactions involving these individuals.

Those allegations require documentary examination and judicial findings before personal wrongdoing or precise amounts of improper enrichment are treated as established facts.

But the existence of unresolved questions is precisely why I am demanding further investigation.

A Public Relations Victory Is Not the Same as Investor Recovery

The BCSC has repeatedly publicized its enforcement efforts against Earle and me.

It has pursued significant penalties and collection proceedings, including proceedings involving retirement assets.

Yet I believe the Commission has failed to provide adequate public answers about other individuals and transactions potentially responsible for substantial investor losses.

The central issue is accountability.

If the Commission's purpose is investor protection, why not publicly explain whether it examined the transactions involving O'Dowd, Lennie, and Tansowny? Tansowny I found out later was sanctioned by the Alberta Securities Commission but the BCSC seemed to have no interest. Tansowny contacted the BCSC and shared information to create pressure on Earle and I when we were pursuing him legally for “skip transfers” and stealing millions with his associates in Alberta. But the BCSC had no interest as our story was a good one for their public relations.

WHY?

Why not explain whether those transactions generated recoverable claims?

Why not provide investors with a clear accounting of what has been recovered and what further recovery efforts are underway?

The BCSC's findings established regulatory wrongdoing by Earle and me. They did not establish that every relevant financial transaction involving FIC had been fully investigated or that every potentially responsible third party had been pursued.

I believe the Commission's continued focus on its historical victories has distracted from these unanswered questions.

The Facts Got in the Way of a Good Media Story

The story presented to the public has been simple.

Two businessmen raised millions. Investors lost money. The regulator imposed penalties.

But the full financial story is more complicated.

The BCSC itself acknowledged that the bulk of the $21.7 million benefited FIC companies.

The Commission did not find that the fraud was designed to enrich Earle and me personally.

And I maintain that Earle and I each lost more personal money than any other individual investor.

These facts deserve serious attention.

They do not erase the Commission's findings, but they challenge an incomplete public portrayal of our financial circumstances and motivations.

Meanwhile, allegations concerning substantial financial benefits received by other participants in Alberta property transactions deserve independent scrutiny.

The public deserves more than a simplified narrative.

Investors deserve to know where their money went.

My Challenge to the BCSC

I challenge the Commission to address five questions.

  1. Why has the BCSC not given greater public attention to its own finding that the bulk of the $21.7 million benefited FIC companies?
  2. Why has the Commission not clearly explained the distinction between its fraud findings and the absence of a finding that the conduct was designed to enrich Earle and me personally?
  3. What investigation, if any, was undertaken concerning Denis O'Dowd, Malcolm Lennie, John Tansowny, and the relevant Alberta property transactions? Why was none of the 350000 I paid to the BCSC paid to investors and where did that money go that I paid in April of 2023?
  4. Has the Commission reviewed Alberta Court File No. 2003 19532 and the related efforts to establish liability for Phoenix Land Ventures' debts?
  5. How much money has the Commission recovered for affected FIC investors, and what efforts have been made to identify additional sources of recovery?

These are fair questions.

The Commission should answer them with documents, financial evidence, and a transparent account of its investigative and recovery efforts.

We Lost Our Money. The Investors Lost Their Money. Who Benefited?

Earle and I paid an enormous financial price when FIC collapsed.

Our businesses failed. Our investments suffered. Our reputations were destroyed.

I maintain that our personal losses were greater than those of any other individual FIC investor.

The BCSC's own decision confirms that the bulk of the $21.7 million benefited the FIC companies, rather than establishing that those funds were personally pocketed by us.

And yet, after more than a decade, the Commission continues to focus its public enforcement narrative on Earle and me.

I believe the time has come to examine the entire financial history, including the people who allegedly benefited from transactions involving FIC funds.

My challenge to the BCSC is direct: Follow the money. Investigate the financial beneficiaries. Explain your decisions. Pursue every person against whom the evidence supports a legitimate claim.

The investors deserve more than press releases.

They deserve answers.

They deserve a complete accounting of where their money went.

And they deserve a regulator willing to examine the entire story, including the facts that complicate its preferred public narrative.

Michael Lathigee
Founder, Freedom Investment Club

September 2026

THE BCSC'S PURSUIT OF VICKI PASQUILL: WHEN DOES GOVERNMENT POWER GO TOO FAR?

September 2026

I recently wrote about what I believe has become an excessive and unfair campaign by the British Columbia Securities Commission against my former business partner, Earle Pasquill.

There is another part of this story that deserves equal attention.

The BCSC has spent years pursuing Earle's wife, Vicki Pasquill, and Vicker Holdings Ltd., a company she controls.

I believe the pursuit of Vicki raises an even broader question about government power.

Vicki was not a respondent in the original BCSC sanctions proceeding against Earle and me.

She was not found responsible for operating the Freedom Investment Club companies.

She was not found to have directed or controlled FIC.

She was not ordered to disgorge $21.7 million.

Yet years later, Vicki and property associated with her became targets of an extraordinary BCSC collection campaign.

And when the BCSC encountered serious legal problems with the case it originally brought against her, the existence of new, retroactive legislation gave the regulator another route to continue.

That history deserves public attention.

THE BCSC WENT AFTER VICKI

The BCSC commenced its collection action in 2018.

It pursued Earle, Vicki and eventually Vicker Holdings.

The Commission sought to reach substantial property and asserted claims including knowing receipt, unjust enrichment, fraudulent conveyance and fraudulent preference.

Those are serious allegations.

But allegations are not findings.

Vicki fought the BCSC in court.

And in 2021, she achieved an important victory.

THE BCSC'S ORIGINAL CASE WAS LARGELY STRUCK

In British Columbia Securities Commission v. Pasquill, 2021 BCSC 1047, the British Columbia Supreme Court struck the substantial majority of the BCSC's claims against Vicki and Vicker.

That fact deserves to be stated plainly.

The BCSC brought the case.

Vicki challenged it.

And most of the claims were struck.

The Court found significant portions of the BCSC's case legally deficient and concluded that claims had been advanced without the necessary statutory authority.

For an ordinary person fighting a government regulator, that should have been a significant moment.

But it was not the end.

Because by then the law had changed.

THE GOVERNMENT HAD CREATED NEW RETROACTIVE COLLECTION POWERS

In 2020, British Columbia amended the Securities Act.

Part 18.1 gave the BCSC substantially expanded collection powers.

Among those powers was a new statutory mechanism allowing the Commission to pursue what the legislation calls "claimable property" transferred to family members and other third parties.

And here is the part I believe the public needs to understand:

Those powers were expressly made retroactive.

Think about what that means in this case.

The events underlying the FIC proceeding occurred in 2008.

The BCSC began its collection action against Vicki and Vicker in 2018.

The Legislature created broader collection powers in 2020.

Those new powers reached backward.

Then, in 2021, most of the BCSC's existing claims against Vicki and Vicker were struck.

But the BCSC was given an opportunity to pursue relief under the newer statutory provisions.

The Commission eventually did exactly that.

It returned to court relying upon powers enacted years after the events and transfers at issue.

That is the point I find so troubling.

TO BE PRECISE ABOUT WHAT HAPPENED

I want to be completely accurate about the chronology.

I am not claiming that British Columbia passed Part 18.1 specifically because Vicki defeated the BCSC in 2021.

That would be incorrect.

The legislation was enacted in 2020, before the 2021 decision striking most of the BCSC's claims against Vicki and Vicker.

But what happened next is documented.

The BCSC's original case against Vicki and Vicker suffered a major setback.

Most of those claims were struck.

The Commission then had available to it expanded collection powers enacted after its original lawsuit began.

Those powers were expressly retroactive.

The BCSC relied upon them to continue pursuing Vicki and Vicker.

That distinction makes the story more accurate.

It does not make it less troubling.

THE BCSC CAME BACK

In 2023, the BCSC sought permission to amend its case and rely upon Part 18.1.

The British Columbia Supreme Court permitted the amendments.

Vicki and Vicker argued, among other things, that the revised claims should not survive the applicable limitation period.

They appealed.

In Pasquill v. British Columbia (Securities Commission), 2025 BCCA 287, the British Columbia Court of Appeal unanimously allowed the BCSC's amended case to proceed.

The Court determined that the amendments did not amount to a new and distinct cause of action for limitation purposes because the essential factual foundation was already present in the earlier proceeding.

That is the law as determined by the Court.

My concern is different.

My concern is fairness.

THE LAW DID NOT GIVE THE BCSC THESE POWERS WHEN THE UNDERLYING EVENTS OCCURRED

This point should not become buried in legal terminology.

Part 18.1 did not exist in 2008.

It did not exist when the events underlying the FIC case occurred.

It did not exist when the BCSC originally pursued Earle and me.

It did not even exist when the BCSC commenced its collection action against Vicki in 2018.

The Legislature enacted these expanded powers in 2020.

And it expressly gave them retroactive reach.

The BCSC is now relying upon those later-created powers in litigation involving Vicki.

The courts have determined that the legislation permits this.

But legality and fairness are different questions.

Government has the ability to change laws.

A legislature also possesses the constitutional authority, within limits, to give legislation retrospective or retroactive effect.

But when government gives a regulator new collection powers and permits those powers to reach backward into transactions occurring before the legislation existed, the public has every right to scrutinize what follows.

THE PARALLEL WITH EARLE'S RETIREMENT MONEY

There is another reason this troubles me.

Look at what happened with Earle's retirement accounts.

The BCSC attempted to preserve Earle's Life Income Fund accounts.

Earle challenged the BCSC.

In 2021, the British Columbia Court of Appeal agreed with Earle and revoked the preservation order.

The Court concluded that pension legislation protected those funds from the BCSC's preservation order.

Once again, Earle had successfully challenged the regulator.

Legislation subsequently changed.

The BCSC returned.

Today it is able to reach mandatory payments coming from those retirement accounts.

Now consider what happened with Vicki.

The BCSC pursued her.

She fought back.

In 2021, most of the BCSC's claims against her and Vicker were struck.

But expanded retroactive collection legislation was now available.

The BCSC returned relying upon those expanded statutory powers.

In both situations, people successfully challenged the reach of the BCSC.

In both situations, the legal framework available to the BCSC expanded.

And in both situations, the regulator continued pursuing the assets.

I find that deeply troubling.

A government agency should not become virtually impossible to defeat because every successful legal challenge is followed by another statutory route allowing the pursuit to continue.

FOLLOW THE MONEY, NOT THE FAMILY

There is another principle I believe matters.

If the BCSC believes Earle transferred recoverable property to Vicki or Vicker, prove it.

Identify the transfer.

Identify the date.

Identify the amount.

Identify the source of the money.

Identify the recipient.

Then connect that specific money to the specific property the Commission seeks to recover.

Property by property.

Transfer by transfer.

Dollar by dollar.

That is how a collection case of this magnitude should be examined.

The fact that Vicki is Earle's wife should not substitute for tracing.

The total value of property owned by Vicki or Vicker should not substitute for tracing.

And the existence of a judgment against Earle should not turn every asset connected to his wife into money obtained from FIC investors.

If Earle transferred recoverable money into a particular property, establish the evidence.

If Vicki contributed her own money, equity or other consideration, establish that as well.

Then let a court determine what portion, if any, is properly recoverable.

That approach protects investors without abandoning fairness.

THE NUMBERS MAKE THIS EVEN MORE IMPORTANT

The scale of the BCSC's pursuit makes careful tracing especially important.

Public reporting on the litigation describes the BCSC collection action as targeting property worth more than $17 million allegedly transferred to Vicki and Vicker.

That is an enormous amount of property.

The value of property caught in a collection proceeding is not automatically the same thing as the amount of investor money proven to have gone into that property.

Those numbers should never be casually treated as interchangeable.

The government should establish the connection.

If $100,000 was improperly transferred into a property worth $2 million, identify the $100,000 and establish the legal basis for whatever recovery the statute permits.

If the government alleges the entire $2 million is recoverable, it should establish the evidence and statutory basis for that position.

That distinction is fundamental.

VICKI WAS NOT SANCTIONED IN THE ORIGINAL CASE

This fact should never disappear from the discussion.

Vicki was not one of the people sanctioned in the original BCSC proceeding.

The $21.7 million disgorgement order was not entered against her.

The $15 million administrative penalty imposed against Earle was not imposed against her.

Yet she has spent years defending herself, her company and substantial property from the BCSC's collection efforts.

Whatever one's opinion of Earle or me, Vicki's position should be judged on the evidence concerning Vicki.

Not on guilt by association.

Not because she married Earle.

Not because the BCSC has been unable to collect its enormous judgment from Earle.

And not simply because legislation enacted years later gives the regulator extraordinary powers to pursue property transferred to family members.

THE CASE HAS NOW REACHED CANADA'S HIGHEST COURT

Vicki has continued fighting.

Following the 2025 British Columbia Court of Appeal decision, Vicki and Vicker Holdings applied for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada.

The case is:

Vicki Irene Pasquill, et al. v. British Columbia Securities Commission

Supreme Court of Canada File No. 42049.

The Supreme Court's own case summary identifies the issues as involving limitation periods and "retrospective legislation."

The Court's docket records that Vicki filed her application for leave to appeal in October 2025.

The BCSC responded.

Vicki replied.

On June 8, 2026, all materials on the application for leave were submitted to the judges for consideration.

The dispute therefore raises legal questions serious enough to have been taken all the way to Canada's highest court.

WHEN DOES ENOUGH BECOME ENOUGH?

This case started with events occurring almost two decades ago.

Earle has been sanctioned.

He has lost financially.

The BCSC continues pursuing his retirement payments.

And his wife has spent years defending herself and her property against the regulator.

The BCSC's original collection claims against Vicki and Vicker largely failed in 2021.

Yet that did not end the pursuit.

Newer legislation containing expressly retroactive collection powers provided another route.

The BCSC took it.

Perhaps the courts will ultimately determine that every step of this collection campaign falls within the powers granted by the Legislature.

But the public is entitled to ask a different question.

Has the BCSC pushed too far?

My answer is yes.

There must be limits to government enforcement.

There must be proportionality.

There must be finality.

And when government relies upon laws enacted years after the underlying events to reach property belonging to someone who was never sanctioned in the original proceeding, fairness deserves at least as much attention as collection.

THE PRINCIPLE SHOULD BE SIMPLE

If Vicki received recoverable property from Earle, prove it.

Trace it.

Show where it went.

Show what asset it purchased.

Show how much of that asset represents the recoverable transfer.

Then seek the remedy the evidence supports.

But do not turn a $21.7 million judgment against Earle into an assumption that everything belonging to his wife represents investor money.

Do not confuse the value of property with the amount allegedly transferred.

Do not confuse an allegation with a finding.

And do not ignore the significance of a government regulator relying upon retroactive powers that did not exist when the underlying events occurred.

Vicki fought the BCSC and succeeded in having most of its original claims against her struck.

The BCSC did not walk away.

It relied upon a new legal framework with expanded retroactive powers and continued the fight.

That is lawful according to the court decisions to date.

I still believe it is wrong.

Government power should have boundaries.

Winning against a government regulator should mean something.

And when the rules available to the regulator expand after the events, after the alleged transfers and even after the original collection lawsuit began, the public should pay close attention.

I have said throughout the FIC story that justice should follow the money.

The same principle applies here.

Follow the money.

Prove the transfers.

Prove the connection to each property.

Recover what the evidence and law establish is recoverable.

But do not destroy another person's financial life simply because she is married to someone the government has pursued for nearly two decades.

At some point enforcement stops looking like investor protection and starts raising serious questions about the limits of government power.

In my opinion, the BCSC's pursuit of Vicki Pasquill has reached that point.

September 2026

THE BCSC, EARLE PASQUILL AND A QUESTION OF FAIRNESS

By Michael Lathigee | September 2026

I have written extensively about my history with the British Columbia Securities Commission and the collapse of the Freedom Investment Club group of companies.

I am not writing this article to retry the original BCSC case.

I am writing because what is now happening to my former business partner, Earle Pasquill, raises serious questions about fairness, proportionality and the extraordinary power of a government regulator to continue pursuing an individual almost two decades after the events at issue.

I believe people deserve to understand the complete story.

The public narrative created around Earle and me has always been simple: investors lost $21.7 million, therefore Earle and Mike personally obtained $21.7 million.

That is not what happened.

The BCSC's own legal theory did not require a finding that Earle or I personally received $21.7 million.

The British Columbia Court of Appeal explained this distinction when reviewing the disgorgement provisions of the Securities Act. The disgorgement orders against Earle and me were upheld because we exercised control and direction over corporate entities that obtained the investor funds. The Court specifically explained that the statutory concept of an "amount obtained" did not require a profit calculation.

That distinction is enormous.

Corporate receipt of money is not the same as personal enrichment.

Neither Earle nor I walked away from FIC with $21.7 million.

We did not become wealthy because FIC investors lost money.

To the contrary, Earle and I lost substantial amounts of our own money when the businesses collapsed.

This is one of the most important facts in this entire story.

WHERE DID THE MONEY GO?

There is another side of the FIC collapse that I believe has never received the attention it deserves.

Substantial amounts of money disappeared through transactions involving other people and entities.

I have published documents on this website concerning John Tansowny, Dennis O'Dowd and others. Those materials describe transactions that I believe resulted in millions of dollars being improperly taken from FIC and its shareholders.

These are not minor issues.

There were real transactions, real properties, real companies and real money.

There were people who financially benefited from transactions involving FIC assets.

My position has always been simple.

Follow the money.

Determine who received it.

Determine who kept it.

Determine who personally benefited.

Then pursue those people.

Instead, the BCSC has spent years pursuing Earle and me.

The irony is difficult to ignore.

The BCSC obtained a $21.7 million disgorgement order without needing to establish that Earle and I personally retained $21.7 million. The legal basis for the order included our control over the corporate entities that received investor funds.

That legal distinction has largely disappeared from the BCSC's public messaging.

Read the BCSC's recent press releases and you repeatedly see phrases such as "ill-gotten gains."

A member of the public reading those words would understandably conclude that Earle and I personally put $21.7 million into our pockets.

We did not.

I believe this distinction should matter to anyone interested in justice rather than headlines.

EARLE'S RETIREMENT MONEY

What is happening to Earle today concerns me even more.

Earle has Life Income Fund accounts containing retirement money.

The BCSC wanted those assets.

Earle fought the BCSC over them.

And he won.

In November 2021, the British Columbia Court of Appeal revoked the BCSC's preservation order against Earle's LIF accounts.

The Court concluded that the Pension Benefits Standards Act protected those pension-derived funds.

Justice Mary Newbury wrote that the legislation meant the Commission did not have authority to enforce its judgments against plans derived from pension funds.

That should be understood clearly.

This was not Earle hiding money in a secret offshore bank account.

These were regulated retirement accounts.

The BCSC tried to reach them.

Earle challenged the BCSC.

The British Columbia Court of Appeal agreed with Earle.

Then the law changed.

THE GOVERNMENT CHANGED THE RULES

Following Earle's successful 2021 appeal, British Columbia amended its legislation.

The BCSC then continued its collection efforts under the changed statutory framework.

In December 2024, the British Columbia Supreme Court ordered payments from Earle's two LIF accounts forfeited to the BCSC.

Earle appealed again.

On March 18, 2026, the British Columbia Court of Appeal upheld the order affecting payments from those retirement accounts.

The BCSC celebrated the result publicly as another legal victory.

I see something entirely different.

I see a government regulator pursuing a man over conduct dating back to 2008, losing a Court of Appeal battle over his protected retirement accounts, benefiting from subsequent legislative changes, and then returning to pursue those retirement payments.

A court has determined the current collection mechanism is lawful.

My opinion concerns fairness.

I do not believe this is fair.

THE RETROACTIVE PROBLEM

There is an even broader issue surrounding the BCSC's collection campaign.

In 2020, British Columbia substantially strengthened the BCSC's collection powers.

These changes occurred approximately twelve years after the events underlying our original case.

Some of the new collection provisions were expressly given retrospective effect.

Separate litigation involving Earle and his family has examined the BCSC's ability to rely upon these expanded collection provisions in relation to transactions predating the amendments.

Think about the principle involved.

The events underlying the FIC case occurred in 2008.

The BCSC imposed sanctions in 2015.

The Legislature subsequently gave the BCSC stronger collection tools.

Earle successfully established in 2021 that his pension-derived accounts were protected from the BCSC preservation order.

The relevant legislation was subsequently changed.

Today the BCSC is taking his mandatory retirement payments.

The courts have determined what the legislation legally permits.

I am entitled to have an opinion about whether the process is fair.

I believe it is profoundly unfair.

PERSONAL RESPONSIBILITY SHOULD MATTER

I am not suggesting regulators should lack enforcement powers.

Securities regulators serve an important purpose.

People who steal investor money should be pursued.

People who personally enrich themselves through wrongdoing should be required to return those gains.

That principle is precisely why the history of FIC deserves closer examination.

Who personally received the money?

Who personally profited?

Who ended up with properties or proceeds purchased with investor funds?

Who lost money?

Those questions should matter.

Earle and I were trying to keep the FIC businesses alive during the 2008 global financial crisis.

The BCSC concluded that we failed to disclose important information about FIC's financial condition and improperly moved money among related companies.

I disagree with important aspects of the BCSC's characterization of what occurred, but those findings are part of the legal record.

There is another fact that belongs in the discussion.

Earle and I did not emerge from the collapse enriched.

We lost substantial amounts of our own money.

Other people benefited financially from transactions involving FIC.

I have spent years presenting information concerning those transactions.

Yet the BCSC's relentless focus has remained on Earle and me.

That is what I find so troubling.

A REGULATOR WITH ENORMOUS POWER

The BCSC describes its mission as protecting investors and maintaining a fair securities market.

Fairness should apply to everyone.

It should apply to investors.

It should also apply to people accused and sanctioned by the regulator.

Government agencies possess resources and powers that individuals simply do not possess.

When an individual successfully establishes a legal protection in the province's highest court, and legislation subsequently changes in a way that allows the regulator to overcome that protection, the public should pay attention.

When expanded collection laws reach conduct and transactions occurring years before those laws existed, the public should pay attention.

When a regulator repeatedly describes corporate investor funds as "ill-gotten gains" without explaining that its disgorgement case did not depend upon proving that Earle and I personally pocketed $21.7 million, the public should pay attention.

And when evidence exists showing that other people financially benefited from transactions involving investor assets, the regulator's response to those people deserves scrutiny as well.

MY VIEW

I have lived with this case for many years.

I know what I invested.

I know what I lost.

I know what Earle lost.

I also know the transactions I have spent years documenting and the people I believe received millions of dollars belonging to FIC companies and shareholders.

People are free to read the BCSC decisions and disagree with me.

I encourage them to read everything.

Read the BCSC decisions.

Read the court decisions.

Read the documents I have published.

Follow the money.

Then decide whether the public narrative tells the complete story.

My opinion is clear.

Earle Pasquill has been punished enough.

Going after his retirement income almost two decades after the underlying events does nothing to change what happened in 2008.

Changing legislation after Earle successfully protected his pension-derived accounts in the Court of Appeal might satisfy the legal requirements created by the Legislature.

In my opinion, it does not satisfy the basic test of fairness.

The BCSC has spent enormous time and resources pursuing Earle and me.

I believe the same determination should have been directed toward tracing the people who personally benefited from the collapse of FIC and recovering money from those who ended up with investor assets.

Justice should focus on facts.

It should follow the money.

And it should apply the rules fairly, even when doing so produces a result a government regulator does not like.

That is my opinion.

Readers should review the evidence and reach their own.

January 2026

BCSC Does Not Want to Know the Truth:

Dear Reader and BCSC: (who stalks my page)
This post presents, as of January 23, 2026, documents and records alleging serious misconduct by John Tansowny, Dennis O’Dowd, and related entities connected to the Freedom Investment Club Group of Companies collapse.
The material attached outlines the financial misconduct, including skip-transfer land transactions, undisclosed conflicts, and payments linked to Phoenix Land Holdings, Crown Capital, and affiliated parties. Investors lost substantial funds during these transactions stolen by Tansowny and O’Dowd.
The British Columbia Securities Commission received this information. The BCSC enforcement action focused on Lathigee and Earle Pasquill. BCSC counsel acknowledged no personal financial gain by either party.
BCSC enforcement decisions appear driven by public perception. Media coverage by the Vancouver Sun played a central role. Reporting by David Baines and Gordon Hoekstra shaped public narrative used by the regulator.  A case of the “tail wagging the dog”.
BCSC actions show no effort to pursue individuals accused of directly profiting from investor losses. Enforcement strategy instead targeted parties linked to media optics.  Tansowny had past sanctions by regulators, but the BCSC ignored all this information.
Several years ago, a payment exceeding USD 400,000 went to the BCSC from myself to pay investors. Investors received zero recovery. Details appear elsewhere on this blog. The record reflects a regulator focused on revenue for itself and public relations outcomes. I know this as I called several former FIC investors who received no monies and no contact from the BCSC. 
The attached documents detail payments from Phoenix entities to John Tansowny. Records also describe rapid same-day property transfers. These transactions show properties purchased and resold multiple times. Profits flowed to Tansowny and O’Dowd while investors absorbed losses.  The BCSC has shown no interest in the truth of what occurred. 
During his tenure, John Tansowny and his wholly owned company Crown Capital acquired numerous Edmonton-area land parcels. Evidence shows close coordination with Dennis O’Dowd and Phoenix Land Holdings. Phoenix paid Tansowny from February 2008 through May 21, 2015. Total payments reached USD 678,000.
While Tansowny was acting as VP of Real Estate for FIC Group, multiple land acquisitions resulted in alleged overpayments. Phoenix Land Ventures intervened through skip transfers. Phoenix purchased land, then resold to FIC at sharply higher prices. Transaction specifics appear in the attached materials.
I KNOW THE BCSC READS THIS AND WHY HAVE YOU DONE NOTHING?  YOU ARE NOT INTERESTED IN JUSTICE BUT JUST PR AND NEVER ONCE INVESTIGATED TANSOWNY OR O’DOWD DESPITE ALL THE EVIDENCE.  SHAME ON YOU! 

The British Columbia Securities Commission:

A Watchdog Without Oversight?  

I’ve spent years living with a story I’m fi͏nal‍ly telling. A fight that ho‍llowed me out, yet still fuels my r‌esolve to speak. I w‌ant you to see the imbalance I faced ‌and why reform f⁠eels urgen‌t. The Britis‌h Columb͏ia Securi⁠ties Commiss‍ion, or BCSC, bills itself as g͏uardian of ‌fair capital markets. But wh‌at when the watchdog has no real checks‌? What‍ if the enforcer twis‌ts the fairness it’s me‌ant to defend?
I learned this͏ ⁠the hard way. I buil͏t something, ͏made mistakes, tried to fix them, only to walk into‍ a system where guilt seemed preordained. At the BCS‍C hearing, three adjudicators hardly bothe‍red to take note‍s through two days of defence‍ testimony. When t‍he Commission’s law‌yers sp͏oke, their pens n͏ever paused. The verdict, it seemed, was⁠ sealed before anyone filed closing submi‌ssions.
One principal accusation ce͏ntered on an email I ‌sent to executive John Tansowny, my VP of Real Estate, who‍ was under inter‌n‍al probe fo‌r alleged kickbacks. He pressed for a hefty commi͏ssion.⁠ I replied that no f‌unds would move until the inquiry wrapped. The Commi‍ssion recast that mes⁠sage as an a‍ttempt to conceal our books fr‌om inve⁠stors. Context‍ mattered little. 
Y‍ears on,‍ courts would ‍f‌ind that‍ Tansowny and his partner, Dennis O’Dowd, misappropriated investor funds. I lodged a complaint with the‌ Law Society o͏f Alberta about their attorney, Malcolm Lennie. Le͏nn‍ie faced se‍v‌ere sanctio‍ns and retired, avoiding disbarment. One of the ‍trio even drew the attention of the RCMP C‍ommercial ⁠C͏rime Unit. Yet the Commission never pursued͏ them‍. I ⁠became the headline. 
In ͏the proceedin͏gs⁠, the BCSC’s counsel co‌nceded I hadn’t benefited personally from͏ the collapse and that my losses were more than any other investor. Yet͏the Commission ‍pressed on. The optics, punishme‍nt over principle, seemed to outrun tr‍uth and fairness. T⁠he͏ cas‍e turned personal. Whil͏e I d⁠rafted filings, my mother died. I asked Naylor & Braster in Nevada, which was the law firm for the BCSC,  for a brief extension to a͏ttend her serv‌ice. On the day, three moving trucks‌, three constables, and ten movers arrived to s͏eize property from my home. I could not attend the funeral. Matthew ‍Pru͏itt,‌ then a⁠t Naylor͏ ͏& B⁠ra‌ster, oversaw the raid. Th‍e case now lists partner John Naylor. 
Sixty-eight one-ounce gold coins vanished in the raid. They weren’t in the‌ official inventory. I produc͏ed evidence showing ͏the coins had been se͏ized and named the ‌locksmith who ‌engin‌eered the diver⁠sion and walked off with them. The‌ BCSC showed no ‌appetite to review its own conduct. Afterward, ordinary life collapse‌d. No ability to open a bank accou͏nt. No ability to attain an apa‌rtme͏nt lease. A simple Google sear͏ch erased any chance of normalcy. I e‍ven ͏changed my name to Michael Doyle to‍ carry‍ on and to try to have a normal life that the google search was preventing. 
The BCSC claimed these moves protected investors. The⁠y forced the sale of my Las Vegas home and re‍moved about‌ $45‍0,000 from t‍he p‌roc⁠eeds, saying investors w‍ould be paid. Gordon Hoekstra of the Vancouver Sun ran a photo o⁠f͏the house a⁠nd alle⁠g‌e͏d I bought it w⁠ith⁠ stolen inves‍tor ⁠funds. After I supplied documents showing the purchase was funded ‌by borrowed, repaid money, th͏ere was no retraction. Canada’s news standar‍ds body‌ d‌id nothing. I reached out to numerous investors; none reported receiving funds f⁠rom the sale. It appears the Commis⁠sion kept ‍the proceeds⁠. A formal complaint or public reckoning seems w͏arranted⁠, yet the response was silence. 
The str͏ucture worsens the problem. The BCSC wea͏rs three h‍ats, invest‍igator, prosecutor, judge, ‍within a single organi‌zation. Complai͏n‌ts against the Commission lack independent review; oversigh͏t is feeble at best. Public accountability? More wishful thinking than reality⁠. 
C‍ou‌rts have raised͏ c͏oncerns. In Morabito v. British Columbia (Securities Commi‍ssion), the B.‍C. Court of Appeal foun⁠d t͏he Commis͏s͏ion failed to ͏tell defendants that a key‌ witness was dying, and the witness died before ⁠testifying. The court ru‍led that this omission unde⁠rmine‌d procedural fairness. That case isn’t an outlier. Cross-b‍order reach also haunts thi͏s story. T͏he BCSC tried to enforce a foreign “fine” in Nevada. Nevada law rej‍ects that kind of‍ penalty, especially after a process sho‍r‍t on⁠ impartiality. Still, t͏he Commission pressed me hard while ignoring far more serious mis‌cond‌uct by others.⁠ 
The larger risk sho⁠uld worry‍ you. The BCSC‍ wields sweep‍ing pow⁠er to freeze⁠assets, ban peo͏ple for l‌ife, and wreck rep‍utations. Safeguar⁠d‍s and independent checks⁠ fall far‌ short of what a fair ‌system should demand. I know some will dispute ‌m͏y a⁠c͏count. I ͏ask for one thing: hold reg‍ulators to th‌e same s‍tandards they demand of everyone e⁠lse. Independ⁠en͏t ov‌ersight. Transparency. An en‍d to ͏self-policing that ͏lets misconduct slip by. 
I ch͏ose to rebuild. I work to help others and to kee͏p sp͏eaking, because trut‍h matters. One vo‌ice against a dominant institution can still make a di͏fferen͏ce when people listen. This goes beyond my file. No govern‍ment body, no‍ matter its mission, should operate above‍ the law. Review my case and others. I’ve posted‍ documents at www.mikelathigeestory.com. Focus on the RCMP files‍ and ‍the rulings ⁠against Tansowny and O’Dowd that drew no BCSC interest. They stole investor mon‍ey. The reco⁠rd s⁠hows it. I fought‌ ͏to hold them accountable and succeeded. Iro͏ny arrived when‍ Tansowny contacted the BCSC to raise ‌concerns about me, ͏t‌ri‌ggering a ͏seizure ‌of‍ all a͏ss‌ets. He wanted me starved of resources so I‌’d stop chasing him. I ‌recovered and ke‍pt going. Duri‌n͏g that seizure, the BCSC took over mo‍re than $2 million of investor assets in coloured diamonds and shi͏pped stones across th⁠e United States for bids. Tr‌ade co‌n͏tacts rang me, say‌ing ‌some diamonds were swapped for cheaper stones and sen‌t back. The final sale yielded only about $250,000. One troubling episode among many. 
Thank you for hearing me out. I seek understanding and real change. What happened to me should never happen to anyone else. 
Sincerely,
Michael Doyle